Photo of 2 FENIMORE RD, SCARSDALE

2 FENIMORE RD, SCARSDALE

Scarsdale, NY 10583

Full Market Value: $3,046,322

5

Beds

6

Baths

5,400

Sq Ft

0.53

Acres

1925

Built

1 Family ResMEDITERRANEAN

About This Property

Steeped in timeless elegance, this magnificent Mediterranean-style residence dates back to 1925 and offers a rare blend of old-world craftsmanship and gracious scale. With approximately 5,400 square feet of living space and five spacious bedrooms, this home delivers the kind of architectural character and generous proportions that are increasingly difficult to find. From its distinctive Mediterranean design details to the enduring quality of its nearly century-old construction, every element speaks to a home built with care and intention.

Set on a beautifully sized half-acre lot, the property provides an inviting sense of privacy and presence in one of Scarsdale's most desirable settings. Fenimore Road is celebrated for its tree-lined streetscape and proximity to the village center, top-rated Scarsdale schools, and convenient commuter access to Manhattan. This is a remarkable opportunity to own a home of true distinction in a community renowned for its charm, excellence, and enduring appeal — a residence that honors its heritage while awaiting the vision of its next fortunate owner.

Property Information

Property information details
Address2 FENIMORE RD, SCARSDALE
SBL04.05.910A
Property Type1 Family Res
Building StyleMEDITERRANEAN
Zoning10,000 SQFT
Lot Size0.53 acres

Structure Details

Building structure details
Year Built1925
Year Remodeled2008
Living Area5,400 sq ft
Stories2.0
Bedrooms5
Full Baths5
Half Baths2
Kitchens1
Fireplaces3
Exterior Wall06 - Stucco
Heat Type2 - Hot Air
Fuel Type2 - Gas
Central AirYes
Basement Type4 - Full
Finished Basement2,866 sq ft
Condition5 - VERY GOOD

Assessment Values

Land Assessed Value

$825,000

Total Assessed Value

$2,124,200

Full Market Value

$3,046,322

Photo of Tova Bourque

Tova Bourque

Sotheby's

Tova Bourque is an award-winning real estate professional serving Scarsdale, Westchester, and New York City. A long-time Scarsdale homeowner and resident herself, she brings unmatched local market knowledge, community insight, and firsthand understanding of what makes each neighborhood special. Known for her honest, direct approach and fierce advocacy, Tova combines deep expertise with thoughtful attention to detail to help her clients achieve the best possible outcome — every time.

Sales History

Property sales history records
Sale DateSale Price
$495,000

Improvements

Property improvement records
StructureSq Ft
RP2 - PORCH, COVERED329
RP5 - PORCH, UPPER OPEN329
LP7 - PATIO, FLAGSTONE791
RG1 - Garage, 1 Sty Attach864
RP5 - PORCH, UPPER OPEN329
LS4 - POOL, GUNITE3,200
CP5 - CANOPY, ROOF ONLY280
GN1 - Generator, Residenti

Building Permits

Building permit records
DateType
SANITARY DISCHARGE
PLUMBING
TREE REMOVAL
MECHANICAL HEATING
STREET OPENING
BUILDING
BUILDING
BUILDING
BUILDING

Location

Nearby Properties