This distinguished professional building presents a remarkable opportunity in the heart of Scarsdale, one of Westchester County's most prestigious and sought-after communities. Encompassing an impressive 67,572 square feet of space situated on nearly half an acre, this substantial commercial property offers the kind of scale and presence that is exceptionally rare in a village setting known for its charm, walkability, and affluent demographic. Zoned VCO-2, the building is well positioned to accommodate a variety of professional and commercial uses, making it an ideal investment for those seeking a premier address with enduring value.
Originally built in 1954, this property carries the legacy of decades of service to the Scarsdale community and its surrounding areas. The generous floor area provides tremendous flexibility for tenants, owners, and investors alike, whether configured for medical, legal, financial, or other professional offices. With a last recorded sale price of $17,600,000, this is a significant asset that reflects both the strength of the local market and the exceptional desirability of the Scarsdale location. The village's top-rated schools, vibrant downtown, and easy access to Metro-North rail service ensure a steady flow of professionals and clientele, making this property a cornerstone opportunity in one of the region's most coveted addresses.
Property Information
Property information details
Address
2 OVERHILL RD, SCARSDALE
SBL
01.02.12A
Property Type
Professional Buildin
Building Style
Commercial
Zoning
VCO-2
Lot Size
0.46 acres
Structure Details
Building structure details
Year Built
1954
Living Area
67,572 sq ft
Stories
4.0
Condition
E -
Assessment Values
Land Assessed Value
$10,000,000
Total Assessed Value
$15,000,000
Full Market Value
$21,511,545
Tova Bourque
Sotheby's
Tova Bourque is an award-winning real estate professional serving Scarsdale, Westchester, and New York City. A long-time Scarsdale homeowner and resident herself, she brings unmatched local market knowledge, community insight, and firsthand understanding of what makes each neighborhood special. Known for her honest, direct approach and fierce advocacy, Tova combines deep expertise with thoughtful attention to detail to help her clients achieve the best possible outcome — every time.
Sales History
Property sales history records
Sale Date
Sale Price
Deed Book/Page
$17,600,000
62242/3455
Building Permits
Building permit records
Date
Type
Status
Description
CO Date
BAR
OPEN
BAR: ALTERATION TO FACADE, ENTRANCE, & INTERIOR LOBBY / NEW AWNINGS, SIGNAGE, DOORS & REPLACEMENT OF EXISTING DRIVEWAY
RAMP AND RAILING.
STREET OPENING - GENERAL
CLOSED
STREET OPENING FOR CRANE PERMIT FOR ROOFTOP HVAC EQUIPMENT. PHOTOS PROVIDED. WORK SCHEDULE PROVIDED.
BAG METERS: OH1, OH2, OH3, OH4, & OH 5.
EMERGENCY CONTACT: TIM MURPHY - (917) 977-1973
RIG DATE: SATURDAY, FEBRUARY 22, 2025 (BACKUP WEATHER DATE - SATURDAY, MARCH 1, 2025)
BUILDING
CLOSED
5 AIR SOURCE HEAT PUMPS ON ROOF TO REPLACE EXISTING COOLING TOWER ON ROOF AND CHILLER IN BASEMENT
PLUMBING
COMPLETED
30 SPRINKLER HEADS FOR FIRST REPUBLIC BANK, BP#2022-0509
PLUMBING : 2" WATER MAIN
5/12/2023 - inspection passed per Vito in water dept, but they need new meter installed before permit is closed.
1/02/2024 - Vito confirmed new meter has been installed, so permit closed.
STREET OPENING - WATER SERVICE
CLOSED
STREET OPENING - NEW WATER SERVICE
PLUMBING
COMPLETED
PLUMBING : BP #2022-509 / 1ST REPUBLIC BANK
COMMERCIAL TENANT BUILD OUT
READY FOR CO
FIRST REPUBLIC BANK TENANT FIT OUT
12/27/22: When CO is issued for this permit, mark Demo permit as completed / BP 2022-48
PLUMBING
COMPLETED
BP #2022-54 /COMMERCIAL RENO OF TENANT SPACE "ADVANCED PLASTIC SURGERY"
PLUMBING
OPEN
#2022-00048 5 FIXTURES
BUILDING
CLOSED
INTERIOR BUILD OUT OF OFFICE SPACE / INCLUDES ELECTRICAL, PLUMBING, SPRINKLERS (ADVANCE PLASTIC SURGERY - FOURTH FLOOR)
BUILDING
OPEN
INTERIOR DEMOLITION OF EXISTING COMMERCIAL TENANT SPACE. REMOVAL OF WALLS, CEILINGS, & FLOORING FOR FUTURE FIRST REPUBLIC BANK
12/27/22: Kevin Scully, COO of Scully Construction came by Building Dept to state the Demo Work is complete and remodel has begun; several inspections have already taken place.
When CO is issued for the Remodel BP 2022-509, this permit for Demo Only, can be marked as completed.
PLUMBING
COMPLETED
PLUMBING: BP #147259
BUILDING
CLOSED
INTERIOR RENOVATION TO STE 220
PLUMBING
COMPLETED
PLUMBING - KITCHEN SINK, BP# 147220
BUILDING
CLOSED WITH CERTIFICATE
INTERIOR ALTERATIONS SECOND FLOOR - SUITE 230 (LENOX HILL MIND CARE)
BUILDING
CLOSED WITH CERTIFICATE
INTERIOR ALTERATIONS SECOND FLOOR - SUITE 230 (LENOX HILL MIND CARE)
BUILDING
OPEN
ALTER TWO EXISTING ELEVATORS
PLUMBING
COMPLETED
PLUMBING - #330, 15 FIXTURES, BP#146161
PLUMBING
COMPLETED
PLUMBING - #340, 1 FIXTURE, BP# 146160
BUILDING
CLOSED
TENANT BUILD OUT FOR NY ORTHO SUITE 340
BUILDING
CLOSED
TENANT BUILD OUT FOR NY ORTHO SUITE 330
MECHANICAL HEATING
COMPLETED
ABANDONMENT OF 2-500 GALLON OIL TANKS
PLUMBING
COMPLETED
PLUMBING FOR BP#145735
BUILDING
CLOSED
INTERIOR ALTERATIONS FOR INFUSE LIFE LLC
PLUMBING
COMPLETED
PLUMBING FOR BP#145407 - SUITE 410
PLUMBING
COMPLETED
PLUMBING FOR BP#145405 - SUITE 320
PLUMBING
COMPLETED
PLUMBING FOR BP#145406 - suite 100
BUILDING
CLOSED
INTERIOR ALTERATIONS - KELLER-WILLIAMS SUITE 100
BUILDING
CLOSED
INTERIOR ALTERATIONS (MEDI TRESSE)-SUITE 320
BUILDING
CLOSED
INTERIOR ALTERATION - WEST MED SUITE 410
BUILDING
CLOSED
INTERIOR OFFICE ALTERATION PRIMA ADVISORS STE 215
BUILDING
CLOSED
INTERIOR OFFICE ALTERATION PIROTTI LAW STE 200
PLUMBING
COMPLETED
PLUMBING FOR BP#144752
BUILDING
CLOSED
INTERIOR ALTERATIONS TRACKMAN GOLF SIMULATOR
BUILDING
CLOSED
INTERIOR ALTERATION DR. JOON LEE MEDICAL OFFICE
PLUMBING
COMPLETED
PLUMBING PERMIT: BP #144486 / MERITAGE PROPERTIES / 2ND FLOOR
Removal of existing MRI & installation of new MRI. Work to be performed on Sunday Jan.29,2012 with Scarsdale Police for road closure and traffic protection.
BUILDING
DOUBLE APPLICATION
SIPLAST LIGHTWEIGHT INSULATING CONCRETE TO EXISTING COMMERCIAL BUILDING
BUILDING
CLOSED
INSTALL HAND RAILS AT MAIN ENTRANCE
BUILDING
CLOSED
INTERIOR ALTERATIONS (3rd floor #320 Dr. Thaler)
BUILDING
DOUBLE APPLICATION
Exterior masonry repairs & roofing
BUILDING
CLOSED
Interior alterations (Blue Mountain Capital)
PLUMBING
COMPLETED
Plumbing
BUILDING
CLOSED
Interior Alterations
PLUMBING
COMPLETED
Plumbing
BUILDING
CLOSED
Interior alterations 4th floor
BUILDING
CLOSED
Interior alterations Doctors Office 2nd fl
BUILDING
VOID
VOID PERMIT ISSUED IN ERROR interior alterations
PLUMBING
COMPLETED
Plumbing permit
BUILDING
CLOSED
interior alterations (Blue mountain Capital)
PLUMBING
COMPLETED
PLUMBING PERMIT
BUILDING
CLOSED
INTERIOR ALTERATIONS - 4TH FLOOR
DR. SILVERMAN OFFICES
PLUMBING
NO CO REQUIRED
plumbing permit
BUILDING
CLOSED
Interior alterations (Prima Capitol)
PLUMBING
NO CO REQUIRED
Plumbing Alteration
PLUMBING
VOID
VOID - NOT a Permit
BUILDING
CLOSED
INTERIOR ALTERATIONS
2ND FLOOR / ANTHONY PIRROTTI JR.
BUILDING
CLOSED
INTERIOR ALTERATIONS
4TH FLOOR / ANDY NATHAN
BUILDING
CLOSED
build out tenant space on 3rd floor
BUILDING
CLOSED
build out tenant space at the third floor
BUILDING
OPEN
build out various tenant spaces on 2nd and 3rd floors
BUILDING
CLOSED
build out tenant space at fourth level
BUILDING
OPEN
build out various tenant spaces on 2nd & 3rd floor
BUILDING
OPEN
build out tenant spaces on the 2nd & 3rd floors
BUILDING
CLOSED
build out spaces on the 2nd & 3rd floor
BUILDING
VOID
build out of tenent spaces for Dr. Freidman on 2nd floor