Photo of 42 BUTLER RD, SCARSDALE

42 BUTLER RD, SCARSDALE

Scarsdale, NY 10583

Full Market Value: $2,767,819

5

Beds

3.5

Baths

3,871

Sq Ft

0.48

Acres

1974

Built

1 Family ResCOLONIAL

About This Property

Welcome to this gracious Colonial residence nestled on a beautifully proportioned half-acre lot in one of Scarsdale's most desirable settings. Built in 1974 and offering an impressive 3,871 square feet of living space, this five-bedroom home delivers the kind of room and versatility that today's discerning families seek. The generous layout provides an ideal balance of formal and everyday living areas, with the spacious footprint allowing each room to breathe with comfort and ease.

Set on a 0.48-acre parcel within a coveted 20,000-square-foot zoning district, the property offers both privacy and the potential to truly make this home your own. The classic Colonial architecture lends timeless curb appeal, while the expansive lot provides a wonderful canvas for outdoor entertaining, gardening, or simply enjoying the tranquility of the surrounding landscape.

Living in Scarsdale means access to one of the most acclaimed school districts in the nation, a charming village center with boutique shopping and dining, and a close-knit community atmosphere that is second to none — all just a short commute to Manhattan. This is a rare opportunity to own a substantial home on a premier lot in one of Westchester County's most sought-after communities.

Property Information

Property information details
Address42 BUTLER RD, SCARSDALE
SBL04.02.436
Property Type1 Family Res
Building StyleCOLONIAL
Zoning20,000 SQFT
Lot Size0.48 acres

Structure Details

Building structure details
Year Built1974
Year Remodeled2010
Living Area3,871 sq ft
Stories2.0
Bedrooms5
Full Baths3
Half Baths1
Kitchens1
Fireplaces1
Exterior Wall01 - Wood
Heat Type2 - Hot Air
Fuel Type2 - Gas
Central AirYes
Basement Type4 - Full
Condition4 -

Assessment Values

Land Assessed Value

$1,500,000

Total Assessed Value

$1,930,000

Full Market Value

$2,767,819

Photo of Tova Bourque

Tova Bourque

Sotheby's

Tova Bourque is an award-winning real estate professional serving Scarsdale, Westchester, and New York City. A long-time Scarsdale homeowner and resident herself, she brings unmatched local market knowledge, community insight, and firsthand understanding of what makes each neighborhood special. Known for her honest, direct approach and fierce advocacy, Tova combines deep expertise with thoughtful attention to detail to help her clients achieve the best possible outcome — every time.

Sales History

Property sales history records
Sale DateSale Price
$907,000

Improvements

Property improvement records
StructureSq Ft
RG1 - Garage, 1 Sty Attach529
RP1 - PORCH, OPEN322
RP1 - PORCH, OPEN322

Building Permits

Building permit records
DateType
STORMWATER MANAGEMENT - GENERAL SITE WORK
STREET OPENING - RESIDENTIAL
SANITARY DISCHARGE
BUILDING
PLUMBING
PLUMBING
BUILDING
BUILDING
PLUMBING
BUILDING
MISCELLANEOUS
BUILDING
MISCELLANEOUS
BUILDING

Location

Nearby Properties