Photo of 42 FENIMORE RD, SCARSDALE

42 FENIMORE RD, SCARSDALE

Scarsdale, NY 10583

$2,950,000

Full Market Value: $2,208,088

5

Beds

4

Baths

3,544

Sq Ft

0.57

Acres

1924

Built

1 Family ResTUDOR

About This Property

Steeped in timeless charm, this classic Tudor residence offers a rare blend of 1920s architectural character and generous proportions, set on a beautifully expansive lot of over half an acre in one of Scarsdale's most coveted neighborhoods. Built in 1924, the home showcases the hallmark details and enduring craftsmanship that define the Tudor style, while providing an impressive 3,544 square feet of living space across a gracious floor plan. With five bedrooms, this is a home designed for both comfortable everyday living and effortless entertaining.

The property's exceptional lot size provides a sense of privacy and tranquility that is increasingly rare, offering abundant outdoor space for gardens, recreation, and al fresco gatherings. Situated in the heart of Scarsdale — renowned for its top-rated schools, vibrant village center, and easy commute to Manhattan — this distinguished residence represents a remarkable opportunity to own a piece of architectural history in one of Westchester County's most prestigious communities. This is a home where heritage, space, and location converge in the most compelling way.

Property Information

Property information details
Address42 FENIMORE RD, SCARSDALE
SBL04.02.21
Property Type1 Family Res
Building StyleTUDOR
Zoning10,000 SQFT
Lot Size0.57 acres

Structure Details

Building structure details
Year Built1924
Year Remodeled2011
Living Area3,544 sq ft
Stories1.9
Bedrooms5
Full Baths4
Kitchens1
Fireplaces1
Exterior Wall06 - Stucco
Heat Type2 - Hot Air
Fuel Type2 - Gas
Central AirYes
Basement Type3 - Partial
Finished Basement996 sq ft
Condition5 -

Assessment Values

Land Assessed Value

$1,077,790

Total Assessed Value

$1,539,700

Full Market Value

$2,208,088

Photo of Tova Bourque

Tova Bourque

Sotheby's

Tova Bourque is an award-winning real estate professional serving Scarsdale, Westchester, and New York City. A long-time Scarsdale homeowner and resident herself, she brings unmatched local market knowledge, community insight, and firsthand understanding of what makes each neighborhood special. Known for her honest, direct approach and fierce advocacy, Tova combines deep expertise with thoughtful attention to detail to help her clients achieve the best possible outcome — every time.

Sales History

Property sales history records
Sale DateSale Price
$2,950,000
$1,625,000
$1,175,000

Improvements

Property improvement records
StructureSq Ft
LP8 - PATIO, FLAGSTONE IN641
RG4 - Garage, 1 Sty Detach400

Building Permits

Building permit records
DateType
TREE REMOVAL
SANITARY DISCHARGE
PLUMBING
BUILDING
BUILDING
BUILDING
PLUMBING
BUILDING
STORM WATER
MECHANICAL HEATING
PLUMBING
BUILDING

Location

Nearby Properties