
51 BUTLER RD, SCARSDALE
Scarsdale, NY 10583
$3,350,000
Full Market Value: $4,445,719
5
Beds
5
Baths
5,667
Sq Ft
0.67
Acres
1927
Built
About This Property
This gracious Colonial, built in 1927, offers a rare combination of timeless architectural character and generous proportions set on a beautifully situated 0.67-acre lot in one of Scarsdale's most desirable neighborhoods. With approximately 5,667 square feet of living space and five bedrooms, the home provides an abundance of room for both elegant entertaining and comfortable everyday living. Nearly a century of history is woven into the home's classic design, lending a sense of warmth and distinction that simply cannot be replicated in new construction.
The expansive grounds offer a true retreat, providing privacy and space that are increasingly rare in Westchester's most coveted communities. Scarsdale's renowned school district, vibrant village center, and convenient commuter access to New York City make this an exceptional location for discerning families seeking the finest suburban lifestyle. This is a remarkable opportunity to own a stately residence with enduring appeal in one of the most prestigious addresses in the metropolitan area.
Property Information
| Address | 51 BUTLER RD, SCARSDALE |
| SBL | 04.02.289 |
| Property Type | 1 Family Res |
| Building Style | COLONIAL |
| Zoning | 15,000 SAQFT |
| Lot Size | 0.67 acres |
Structure Details
| Year Built | 1927 |
| Year Remodeled | 2014 |
| Living Area | 5,667 sq ft |
| Stories | 2.0 |
| Bedrooms | 5 |
| Full Baths | 4 |
| Half Baths | 2 |
| Kitchens | 1 |
| Fireplaces | 3 |
| Exterior Wall | 02 - Brick |
| Heat Type | 3 - Hot Water \ Steam |
| Fuel Type | 2 - Gas |
| Central Air | Yes |
| Basement Type | 3 - Partial |
| Condition | 5 - |
Assessment Values
Land Assessed Value
$1,600,000
Total Assessed Value
$3,100,000
Full Market Value
$4,445,719

Tova Bourque
Sotheby's
Tova Bourque is an award-winning real estate professional serving Scarsdale, Westchester, and New York City. A long-time Scarsdale homeowner and resident herself, she brings unmatched local market knowledge, community insight, and firsthand understanding of what makes each neighborhood special. Known for her honest, direct approach and fierce advocacy, Tova combines deep expertise with thoughtful attention to detail to help her clients achieve the best possible outcome — every time.
Sales History
| Sale Date | Sale Price |
|---|---|
| $3,350,000 | |
| $2,430,000 |
Improvements
| Structure | Sq Ft |
|---|---|
| RP4 - PORCH, ENCLOSED | 204 |
| RG1 - Garage, 1 Sty Attach | 585 |
| LP7 - PATIO, FLAGSTONE | 374 |
| LS1 - POOL, STEEL VINYL | 338 |
Building Permits
| Date | Type |
|---|---|
| PLUMBING | |
| INTERIOR ALTERATIONS | |
| TREE REMOVAL | |
| GENERATOR | |
| STREET OPENING | |
| PLUMBING | |
| STORM WATER | |
| BUILDING | |
| MECHANICAL HEATING | |
| PLUMBING | |
| BUILDING | |
| PLUMBING | |
| PLUMBING | |
| SPRINKLER | |
| BUILDING | |
| BUILDING | |
| BUILDING | |
| BUILDING | |
| BUILDING |
Location
Nearby Properties




